The largest amphibian monitoring program in the U.S. may have flaws that, if uncorrected, could result in overestimates of frog populations, North Carolina State University said today.
“Scientists track amphibian populations because these animals are sensitive to changes in their environment and can serve as ‘canaries in the coal mine’ to give researchers early warnings about pollution or other ecological problems,” NC State said in a news release about the research.
“The U.S. Geological Survey launched the North American Amphibian Monitoring Program (NAAMP) in the late 1990s to collect information on the diversity and abundance of frog species. The program is important because interest in amphibian populations has grown over the past 15 years, as scientists have learned that amphibians are environmental indicators that respond very quickly to pollution and environmental degradation,” NC State said.
NAAMP is a citizen-based program that relies on volunteers to travel to sample locations and listen for calling frogs at designated times of the year. These volunteers then report their findings, including which species are heard as well as a rough estimate of the population size, to the USGS, NC State explained.
“Understanding changes in amphibian populations can help us identify potential environmental problems,” said Ted Simons, a professor of biology at NC State, co-author of the new study, and assistant unit leader at the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit.
“Ribbit Radio” consists of a series of remotely controlled playback devices that can be used to mimic populations of calling frogs. The researchers set the system up in a field and used it to test how well observers identify frog species, NC State said.
“Ribbit Radio” consists of a series of remotely controlled playback devices that can be used to mimic populations of calling frogs. The researchers set the system up in a field and used it to test how well observers identify frog species.
Photo courtesy of NC State University
“Simons and his co-authors wanted to test the accuracy of these surveys by using the ‘Bird Radio’ system Simons developed previously to test the accuracy of bird census methods. The system, renamed ‘Ribbit Radio,’ consists of a series of remotely controlled playback devices that can be used to mimic populations of calling frogs. The researchers set up ‘Ribbit Radio’ in a field and used it to test how well observers identify frog species,” NC State explained.
“Observers want to include as many species on their lists as possible, but sometimes our ears play tricks on us.”
Simons says the researchers immediately noted a lot of “false positives” in the data–meaning that some observers were saying they heard species that were not played by the “Ribbit Radio” system. “A lot of it is human nature,” Simons says. “Observers want to include as many species on their lists as possible, but sometimes our ears play tricks on us.”
This could be an important issue for the NAAMP, because the survey uses the presence or absence of species to monitor changes in populations, NC State noted. “Including false positives in the analysis, if not accounted for, can produce a serious bias in these population estimates. USGS has published on how to handle false positives and false negatives in assessing amphibian occurrence data and has ongoing research in this area.”
Better training to fix the problem
Researchers hope that better training can help address this potential problem and improve the accuracy of the NAAMP in the future, Simons said. “Training observers to help reduce false positive errors should improve the quality of the monitoring data,” he said.
“Dr. Simons’ work adds to our understanding of observer error in frog call surveys and more research on this topic is needed,” said Linda Weir, USGS NAAMP Coordinator and one of the participants in the study.
Simons and NAAMP will continue working together this fall on a follow-up study using “Ribbit Radio.”
The current study, “Unmodeled observation error induces bias when inferring patterns and dynamics of species occurrence via aural detections,” is published in the August issue of Ecology. It is co-authored by Simons, NC State’s Kenneth Pollock, Larissa Bailey of Colorado State University and Brett McClintock of the University of St. Andrews.
NC State’s Department of Biology is part of the university’s College of Agriculture and Life Sciences.