REDD and Land Tenure: the Rights Issue

In Panama, where many land-tenure issues have gone unresolved for a long time, the nation’s indigenous communities are closely watching the climate-mitigation plan REDD (“Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation”).

According to most interpretations of the documents involved, REDD’s role in a carbon market in Panama would undermine sovereignty, mostly by providing incentives for the state to wrest control of land and carbon value from indigenous communities, including those that have fought for land tenure. Quoting a host of national environment and forestry laws, the fine print of REDD-related documents includes language like: “The forest heritage of the State [is] in the public domain” and “authority to the State [for] carbon capture.” Translation: “Yes, according to the constitution, the indigenous communities own their forests; but the government owns the trees in the forests.” In anticipation of the carbon market back in 1998, Panamanian legislators recognized carbon sequestration as an “environmental service,” giving the state authority to manage it.

By declaring eminent domain — or the loosely defined “common good,” which the state has the right to equate with national development strategy — the government could not only cut the Kuna out of the carbon market but also sanction clear-cuts for any number of purposes, from plantations to dams. REDD doesn’t abrogate that right at all, nor empower indigenous communities to defend themselves against such infringements. And it could increase the value of some lands, which in turn could increase “exploitation of local communities,” as James Mayers of the International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) recently put it to the New York Times.


Return to the story: Will a UN Climate-Change Solution Help Kuna Yala?

Changing Planet

Meet the Author
More than forty years in U.S., UK, and South African media gives David Max Braun global perspective and experience across multiple storytelling platforms. His coverage of science, nature, politics, and technology has been published/broadcast by the BBC, CNN, NPR, AP, UPI, National Geographic, TechWeb, De Telegraaf, Travel World, and Argus South African Newspapers. He has published two books and won several journalism awards. In his 22-year career at National Geographic he was VP and editor in chief of National Geographic Digital Media, and the founding editor of the National Geographic Society blog, hosting a global discussion on issues resonating with the Society's mission and initiatives. He also directed the Society side of the Fulbright-National Geographic Digital Storytelling Fellowship, awarded to Americans seeking the opportunity to spend nine months abroad, engaging local communities and sharing stories from the field with a global audience. A regular expert on National Geographic Expeditions, David also lectures on storytelling for impact. He has 120,000 followers on social media: Facebook  Twitter  LinkedIn