Does Bear Spray Work?

Contributing Editor, Dr. Jordan Schaul, a member of the IUCN Bear Specialist Group and an ex-officio council member of the International Association for Bear Research and Management, briefly discusses his experience with bear spray.

In the wake of a fatal grizzly bear encounter near Yellowstone National Park, officials have issued a couple of reminders to recreational campers. One suggestion–carry bear spray. And remember to carry it in a holster!

These commercially available lacrymatory agents are derived from chili peppers. The active ingredient–oleoresin capiscum is used as both a defense spray and as a topical pain reliever.  The EPA registered bear deterrents are nothing more than pepper spray, but try telling that to the bear or me for that matter.

Lachrymators stimulate corneal nerves which induce tearing and even temporary blindness.  And they are quite suitable irritants of any tissues lined with mucus membranes.

At the Alaska Wildlife Conservation Center, we carry Counter Assault— CA-18H-Bear Deterrent (10.2 oz with Belt Holster) when we enter enclosures with bears or work with them through protected contact. At nearly $60 a cannister it is expensive stuff, but with a range of 25 feet, the manufacturers suggest it is effective for “sudden close encounter defensive charges (from 15-25 feet),  full defensive charges (from more than 50 feet away), and gradual continuous approaches.”

I find that few people that purchase bear spray have much insight into distinguishing among types of aggressive behaviors in bears. What’s important is that they selected a non-lethal deterent.  Whether it is a provoked charge or an attack with predatory intent, the bear spray will likely ward off a bear.

Make sure you purchase a cannister with a holster. I have been sprayed, albeit accidentally, twice in my career because I was not carrying the spray can in the holster.  

A young bear I was training, inadvertently punctured a cannister and it discharged.  The grizzly headed straight to his pool and I went to clean off. The noxious irritant works. If nothing else it surprises both intended and unintended targets.

With training in wildlife ecology, conservation medicine and comparative psychology, Dr. Schaul's contributions to Nat Geo Voices have covered a range of environmental and social topics. He draws particular attention to the plight of imperiled species highlighting issues at the juncture or nexus of sorta situ wildlife conservation and applied animal welfare. Sorta situ conservation practices are comprised of scientific management and stewardship of animal populations ex situ (in captivity / 'in human care') and in situ (free-ranging / 'in nature'). He also has a background in behavior management and training of companion animals and captive wildlife, as well as conservation marketing and digital publicity. Jordan has shared interviews with colleagues and public figures, as well as editorial news content. In addition, he has posted narratives describing his own work, which include the following examples: • Restoration of wood bison to the Interior of Alaska while (While Animal Curator at Alaska Wildlife Conservation Center and courtesy professor at the University of Alaska) • Rehabilitation of orphaned sloth bears exploited for tourists in South Asia (While executive consultant 'in-residence' at the Agra Bear Rescue Center managed by Wildlife SOS) • Censusing small wild cat (e.g. ocelot and margay) populations in the montane cloud forests of Costa Rica for popular publications with 'The Cat Whisperer' Mieshelle Nagelschneider • Evaluating the impact of ecotourism on marine mammal population stability and welfare off the coast of Mexico's Sea of Cortez (With Boston University's marine science program) Jordan was a director on boards of non-profit wildlife conservation organizations serving nations in Africa, North and South America and Southeast Asia. He is also a consultant to a human-wildlife conflict mitigation organization in the Pacific Northwest. Following animal curatorships in Alaska and California, he served as a charter board member of a zoo advocacy and outreach organization and later as its executive director. Jordan was a member of the Communication and Education Commission of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (CEC-IUCN) and the Bear Specialist Group of the IUCN Species Survival Commission (BSG-SSC-IUCN). He has served on the advisory council of the National Wildlife Humane Society and in service to the Bear Taxon Advisory Group of the Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA Bear TAG). In addition he was an ex officio member of council of the International Association for Bear Research and Management. Contact Email: jordan@jordanschaul.com http://www.facebook.com/jordan.schaul https://www.linkedin.com/in/jordanschaul/ www.jordanschaul.com www.bicoastalreputationmanagement.com
  • Dave Smith

    Wind and cold weather can have adverse affects on bear spray performance, but are a non-issue with firearms. It’s a good idea to practice removing bear spray from its holster a few times, but it doesn’t take any real skill or training to use bear spray effectively. To stop a charging bear with a firearm, you’ll need lots of training, lots of luck, or both. There have been two peer reviewed studies on bear spray published in scientific journals. There’s never been a peer reviewed study on firearms published in a scientific journal. Don’t believe bear spray advocates who claim research proves bear spray is more effective than a firearm.

  • Cindy

    Bear Pepper Spray has been proven to be more effective in warding off a bear than a bullet – plus, you won’t kill the bear!

  • Dave

    I’ve had several experiences with black bears, close up. All I had to do is become ferocious and make lots of noise, they bailed out of the confrontation. I did test one of the top bear sprays from Cabelas. I had the wind at my back but forgot that my body created a vacuum in the wind. The spray came back on me. Military vets: remember the gas chamber in basic training? This stuff was 100 times worse. I gaged and coughed, I could not see because of burning eyes. I can only imagine what this stuff would do to a creature that has a nose 1000 times better than ours! If you hit them in the face.
    My opinion, bear spray first, while drawing your .44 or .500 , if the spray doesn’t work, shoot like your life depends on it, because it does!

    • AaronDana Pendleton

      black bears are nothing more than oversized trash pandas.
      you can scare them off with a large stick.

      it would probably have very little effect on a real man eater.

  • Dexter

    Bear sprays work if you know how to use it. Timing is crucial and I always believe that luck has to be on your side. Also, make sure to place it somewhere you can easily grab it – it will be pointless to bring a bear spray and leave it packed inside your camping bag!

  • AaronDana Pendleton

    a bear you were training is not a wild bear.
    you might as well spray a bunny and say how effective it worked.

    I want to see real in the wild first hand experiences on if this crap works or not which I highly doubt it will on anything that really wants to kill you.

About the Blog

Researchers, conservationists, and others share stories, insights and ideas about Our Changing Planet, Wildlife & Wild Spaces, and The Human Journey. More than 50,000 comments have been added to 10,000 posts. Explore the list alongside to dive deeper into some of the most popular categories of the National Geographic Society’s conversation platform Voices.

Opinions are those of the blogger and/or the blogger’s organization, and not necessarily those of the National Geographic Society. Posters of blogs and comments are required to observe National Geographic’s community rules and other terms of service.

Voices director: David Braun (dbraun@ngs.org)

Social Media