Changing Planet

If You Don’t Speak Up, You’re Not Doing Your Job

In today’s polarized climate, it is not uncommon to hear opposition to anything labeled climate-friendly or green. But confronting inaccurate and unfair arguments requires constant effort, and the trend toward complacency is dangerous. According to Jigar Shah of the Carbon War Room at the American Renewable Energy Day (AREDAY) conference in Aspen last week, if one doesn’t confront inaccuracies, “you’re not doing your job” and you are part of the problem. The tone of Shah’s message is comparable to the public’s frustration over political inaction.

Hunter Lovins, of Natural Capitalism Solutions, offered similar sentiment. Although we might not have a president who cares enough, “we don’t have a lot of things. We just have us.” There is no need to wait for political agreement in order to take action. Lovins’ work in energy efficiency has found that corporations around the world are already making money by going green. Reducing waste saves energy and resources, hence there’s no need to wait for government leadership.

The good news is that the cost of renewable energy is now competitive. In fact, in some states it costs more to open and run a coal power plant than solar. The main costs for a power plant are construction, maintenance and price of the commodity, which in this case, is coal. Once operational, a solar power plant requires minimal maintenance and sunlight is free. Shah highlighted North Carolina as an example, where solar is now cheaper than coal. And wind versus coal provides an even greater mismatch.

As one might think, it is not subsidies that are providing the difference, Shah explained. In contrast, fossil industry proponents claim that the percentage of subsidies compared to price is higher for renewables than for natural gas. This is accurate because start-up costs are higher for renewables; however, the reasoning is specious, he argued. The key is that the riskiest portion of the natural gas investment, exploration, is subsidized by the government, so if natural gas exploration fails, investors lose virtually none of their investment. On the other hand, investors might make a 25% return if the exploration succeeds. Without a guaranteed subsidy, investors might lose their investment should natural gas exploration fail. Shah pointed out that faced with such a risk, a 25% return might not be sufficient to lure investors; they might seek higher returns elsewhere.*

“Coal is no longer the cheap option,” Hunter Lovins reiterated. “When the General [Wesley Clark] says solar and wind are not ready, call bull—-!” Unfortunately, when the General made this statement earlier in the conference, no one objected. A more concerted effort is needed if we are going to do our job!

* Return estimates taken from the AREDAY conference

Chad Lipton is currently starting a business delivering clean energy services in Cote d’Ivoire. Previously, Chad worked for National Geographic where he managed a grant program to fund entrepreneurs delivering innovative energy solutions to communities facing economic, climate change, environmental and other challenges. In 2013, Chad submitted the winning idea to be the subject matter for National Geographic's challenge competition, called the Terra Watt Prize. He helped develop the prize objective, which is to address the challenges of energy access by facilitating the flow of capital between entrepreneurs and investors and also to identify viable business models. Before National Geographic, Chad worked for Elysian Energy as an energy auditor, carrying out site visits and analysis in the residential energy field. Prior to Elysian Energy, Chad worked in the field of carbon management, where he performed site verification for greenhouse gas emission reduction projects. From 2004-07, Chad worked as an environmental health specialist in Africa carrying out water and sanitation projects in Côte d’Ivoire and Mozambique. Chad has master’s degrees in Environmental Health Science and International Relations from The Johns Hopkins University.

About the Blog

Researchers, conservationists, and others share stories, insights and ideas about Our Changing Planet, Wildlife & Wild Spaces, and The Human Journey. More than 50,000 comments have been added to 10,000 posts. Explore the list alongside to dive deeper into some of the most popular categories of the National Geographic Society’s conversation platform Voices.

Opinions are those of the blogger and/or the blogger’s organization, and not necessarily those of the National Geographic Society. Posters of blogs and comments are required to observe National Geographic’s community rules and other terms of service.

Voices director: David Braun (dbraun@ngs.org)

Social Media