Changing Planet

Happy New Year Bluefin!

A North Pacific Bluefin tuna fetched 56.49m yen/$736,000 at Tsukiji fish market’s first tuna auction of the year.  Bluefin stocks in the Atlantic and South Pacific are depleted to fractions of their original size thanks to overfishing driven primarily by the Japanese sushi market.  Many of us, who may love sushi as much as the next guy but want to avoid unsustainable choices, can’t understand this seemingly insatiable and careless appetite for a threatened species.  Don’t they know that this will only make matters worse for bluefin?

There are several reasons why this is happening:

First, this is a publicity stunt.  Every now and then when an extraordinarily large and fatty N. Pacific bluefin is caught, it is rushed to Tokyo on ice to maximize freshness and value (never frozen like Atlantic or Southern bluefin).  When it shows up at the world famous/infamous (your choice) Tsukiji fish market, the owner of one of the major sushi chains or an upscale restaurant will pay a ridiculously high price as a marketing campaign (note: we in the West are not their audience).

It is also no surprise that it happened now.  New years celebrations are the time to impress your friends and neighbors in Japan by serving the most exquisite sushi you can’t afford, so sushi prices in Japan tend to spike this time of year.  In Japan, serving Toro, or bluefin belly fat, is the ultimate gesture of graciousness towards your guests.

Also, the North Pacific bluefin is the most prized of all the species/stocks by the Japanese.  This is their bluefin caught right off their coast so it will always fetch a higher price.

The last time one of these amazing creatures showed up on the auction block a Hong Kong-based sushi chain was involved in the winning bid.  One more way the rise of China is freaking out the Japanese: this time they are taking away their most prized food!  Throw in the desire to create some sense of optimism in post-tsunami Japan and naturally the “Sushi Audacity Cup” had to be brought home to Tokyo.  After all, they needed to reclaim their national culinary treasure.

If you are still scratching your head, you’re not alone.  But, all joking aside, before we criticize the Japanese, think back to our own experience with cod, orange roughy and now Chilean sea bass.   The answer is not to disparage someone else’s culture but to try to understand, respect and work with all the people of the world to make sure there are plenty of fish in the sea for all of us to enjoy in different ways.

Miguel Angel Jorge is the Managing Director of 50in10, working to expand the organization's network of stakeholders, facilitate knowledge sharing about sustainable fisheries management, and help design and support collaborative fishery restoration programs implemented by the organization's partners around the world. Before joining 50in10, Miguel was Director of the National Geographic Society’s Ocean Initiative, which strives to restore the ocean’s health and productivity. He joined NGS in February of 2010. Previously Miguel worked as Director of WWF-International’s Marine Program, where he oversaw the their global strategies on fisheries and seafood, shipping and high-seas conservation policy. Before that Miguel worked extensively in Latin America and the Caribbean on marine, freshwater conservation and large-scale conservation planning processes, in the Gulf of California, Galapagos and Mesoamerican Reef. In his early career, Miguel worked in a wide array of areas, from aquaculture to refugee camp conflict mediator, to delegate at UN meetings. A native of Cuba, he has also lived in the US, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic and Switzerland. Miguel has a Masters in Marine Policy and a Bachelor’s in Aquatic Biology.

About the Blog

Researchers, conservationists, and others share stories, insights and ideas about Our Changing Planet, Wildlife & Wild Spaces, and The Human Journey. More than 50,000 comments have been added to 10,000 posts. Explore the list alongside to dive deeper into some of the most popular categories of the National Geographic Society’s conversation platform Voices.

Opinions are those of the blogger and/or the blogger’s organization, and not necessarily those of the National Geographic Society. Posters of blogs and comments are required to observe National Geographic’s community rules and other terms of service.

Voices director: David Braun (dbraun@ngs.org)

Social Media