Changing Planet

Missing Martian Atmosphere: Clues In Earth’s Cold Plasma?

Illustration courtesy J. Huart, ESA

It’s been an incredible week for space weather, thanks to a nasty sunspot that hurled a cloud of superheated gas and charged particles toward the Earth.

But some cooler space weather news has snuck into the mix: “Invisible” veils of cold plasma were discovered around Earth, and they might tell us something about Mars’s missing atmosphere.

First, a little bit more on the discovery.

Two space scientists poring over data from the European Space Agency’s Cluster II satellites—four spacecraft which zip around Earth in an elliptical orbit—found evidence of positively charged, slow-moving (hence “cold”) plasma particles as far as 60,000 miles (100,000 kilometers) above Earth’s surface.

That’s about a quarter of the way to the moon, and a region where few researchers suspected any cold plasma lurked. But nobody needs to be hard on themselves, said space scientist Mats André of the Swedish Institute of Space Physics (and leader of the new study about the plasma in Geophysical Research Letters). That’s because cold plasma is really, really tough to detect.

The invisibility of cold matter has a lot to do with like charges repelling like charges. Sunlight in space strips away electrons from atoms, ionizing any “naked” matter out there to have a positive charge. That includes spacecraft (like Cluster II satellites) and atmospheric gas at the edge of Earth’s atmosphere (which creates cold plasma).

Like a magnet’s north pole near another magnet’s north pole, the spacecraft and cold plasma repel and never meet. “Hot” plasma, on the other hand, is moving fast enough to ignore any magnetic repulsion with a spacecraft, so it’s detectable.

Without some clever analysis, cold plasma just doesn’t seem to be out there.

But André knew two things. First, that a spacecraft zooming through cold plasma—if it existed—would create a shockwave (i.e. cold plasma piling in front and zipping around to the back). Second, moving charged particles emit electric fields.

André and his colleague paired these facts up to “see” the subtle shockwaves in Cluster II’s data. The results imply cold matter constitutes between 50 and 70 percent of all charged particles in Earth’s magnetic field! That’s quite a jump from zero percent.

The sudden abundance of cold plasma means a few things. Space weather forecasts stand to improve, as cold plasma particles probably interact with incoming hot matter from solar storms—and that dynamic is missing from computer models. Another effect is that the Earth is bleeding off roughly 2.2 pounds (1 kilogram) of atmospheric gas every second.

When you look at planets with thin atmospheres like Mars (which has just 1 percent the atmospheric pressure of Earth), scientists like André begin to wonder what role the “blood loss” of cold plasma plays in killing atmospheres.

Illustration couretsy NASA/JPL-Caltech

Despite having half the solar intensity, the rate of loss may be about the same as it is at Earth (about one Chihuahua’s weight every second).

“There are all kinds of ways to get rid of a planet’s atmosphere—big asteroid impacts, loss of a dynamo, and so on,” André said. “Well, this is certainly one of them when you apply it over billions of years of time. I don’t know how important it is, but this is on my short list.”

While no one knows for certain how Mars lost its atmosphere, we now have a chilly new suspect.

Dave Mosher is a freelance journalist obsessed with space, physics, biology, technology and more. He lives in New York City and you can stalk him on Twitter as @davemosher.

  • Dakota

    Why would you care about this in the short term?
    For Earth to loss its Atmosphere at the rate you calculated; it would take 158443823077 years.

  • Dakota

    Why would you care about this in the short term? The rate you calculated we were losing the atmosphere around Earth. It would take just under 10 billion years.

  • Gary Gilligan

    Mars most definitely lost its dynamo; it is now the ‘iron’ planet we call Mercury. It was ‘magnetically’ extracted through Mars’ enormous great chasm, the ‘Valles Marineris’ in a period of catastrophic planetary encounters with earth (& Venus) only a few thousand years ago. This is why the diameter of Mercury is approximately the same length as the Valles Marineris. Once Mars (home) lost its working dynamo (solid iron core = Mercury) its once earth-like conditions i.e. atmosphere, oceans, flora, fauna, etc. were either boiled off or blasted off by the solar wind.
    Gary Gilligan

  • […] (Find out how cold plasma might also help explain why Mars is missing its atmosphere.) […]

  • jgfox

    Fascination discovery!

    I’m not going to stock up on Oxygen yet because of the “Chihuahua depletion effect.”

    2.2 lbs per second translates to 31.5 *10 to 15th power of lbs lost per billion years

    Weight of earth’s atmosphere is in lbs 11.7*10 to the 18th power

    Total loss would be in about 370 billion years.

    Mars did lose its early atmosphere, but there are a lot of other factors …especially the weaker gravity and the uncertainty of its starting mass.

    Earth can replenish it’s atmospheric Oxygen content by the vast reserves of water and biological activity, and its Nitrogen content by the Nitrogen Cycle biological cycle.

  • […] Missing martian atmospere […]

About the Blog

Researchers, conservationists, and others share stories, insights and ideas about Our Changing Planet, Wildlife & Wild Spaces, and The Human Journey. More than 50,000 comments have been added to 10,000 posts. Explore the list alongside to dive deeper into some of the most popular categories of the National Geographic Society’s conversation platform Voices.

Opinions are those of the blogger and/or the blogger’s organization, and not necessarily those of the National Geographic Society. Posters of blogs and comments are required to observe National Geographic’s community rules and other terms of service.

Voices director: David Braun (

Social Media