Wildlife & Wild Places

How the Yampa River, and its Dependents, Survived the Drought of 2012

As this year’s drought deepened and spread across the United States, many cities and farms took steps to cope.  Bans on landscape irrigation conserved municipal supplies.  Farmers pumped more groundwater for their crops to make up for the lack of rain.

But what’s a river to do?

Most rivers are last in line for help during dry spells.  Their flows disappear, their fish go belly up, and their riverside habitats for birds and wildlife dry out and wither.

Although droughts are natural, and rivers have adapted to them, what’s unnatural is the extensive damming and diverting of their flows to satisfy growing human needs for drinking water, irrigation, energy production, and flood control.  Those are important benefits, to be sure, but the flow alteration causes ecological harm even in wet years. When a drought strikes, rivers – and the life they sustain – often take a terrible hit.

By late spring, a bad summer seemed to be in store for the Yampa River in the upper Colorado River Basin.  The Yampa flows 250 miles (400 kilometers) across a storied valley of farms and ranches in northwestern Colorado, through the popular tourist town of Steamboat Springs, and west to Dinosaur National Monument, where it joins the Green River near the Utah border.  On May 1, the snowpack that feeds the Yampa’s flow was 17 percent of average; by June 1 it was 6 percent.

“We were preparing for a devastatingly poor summer,” said Peter Van De Carr, owner of Backdoor Sports, situated on the banks of the Yampa in the heart of Steamboat.

The river’s flows dropped throughout the month of June.  On Tuesday the 19th, it ran at 85 cubic feet per second (cfs), a key benchmark for local businesses because many recreational activities on the river are curtailed when flows drop below that level.

Van De Carr, who outfits customers with kayaks and tubes, saw dollars draining out of his cash register.

By June 27, the river’s flow had dropped to 40 cfs, just 5 percent of normal for that day of the year.  Van de Carr and others worried about a repeat of 2002, the last severe drought in the region, when the Yampa dropped to 17 cfs, killing fish that couldn’t get enough oxygen or food, slamming local businesses at the height of summer tourist season, and generally decimating the ecosystem and the economy that depends on it.

That summer of 2002, the river “smelled like rotting seaweed,” Van De Carr recalled.  “It was a nightmare.”

A Water Lease to the Rescue

But 2012 would turn out differently.  On Friday, June 29, as if by a miracle, the river started to rise.  By 9:30 that night, it was flowing at 71 cfs.

Something had happened that had never happened before in Colorado:  an intervention to spare a river – and its dependents – from decimation during a drought.

Back in the spring, when the skimpy mountain snowpack spelled disaster for so many of Colorado’s rivers and streams, the non-profit Colorado Water Trust (CWT) issued a statewide request for water.  Anyone willing to sell or temporarily lease water was encouraged to contact the CWT.  If the water could help a river weather the drought, the CWT would consider buying it.

One answer to the call came from Kevin McBride, director of the Upper Yampa Water Conservancy District in Steamboat Springs.  McBride had just had a contract with a customer fall through, leaving 4,000 acre-feet (1.3 billion gallons) of Yampa River water unclaimed in Stagecoach Reservoir.  For the right price, McBride was willing to lease that water to the Colorado Water Trust.

“We rocketed that (project) to the top of our priorities,” said Amy Beatie, Executive Director of the water trust, based in Denver.

“It looked like a system that was ecologically going to crash,” Beatie said. “The river was starting to crater.”

So for a total of $140,000, or $35 per acre-foot, CWT leased the water district’s spare water.  McBride had set the price, based on what he knew his board would approve.  In that part of the West, the cost was very reasonable.

On June 28, the leased water began flowing out of Stagecoach Reservoir into the Yampa. The extra flow would directly benefit seven crucial miles downstream of the reservoir, as well as the river’s course through Steamboat and beyond.  The idea was to keep the river as healthy as possible through the summer, by releasing about 26 cfs a day into September.

Along the way, the leased water provided multiple benefits.  It generated extra hydropower at the Stagecoach Reservoir.  It provided aesthetic and recreation benefits in Steamboat, helping businesses like Backdoor Sports avoid tens of thousands of dollars in lost revenues.  Further downstream of the reach targeted for the lease, some irrigators even got more water for their crops, a welcome boost during a drought and dire economic times.

“The purpose of the lease is to maximize the beneficial use of water in Colorado,” Beatie explained.  “These incidental benefits make this a win-win-win-win. “

Besides rescuing a river and its dependents, the Yampa drought-lease set a precedent in Colorado.  It was the first use of a 2003 state law, passed in part in response to the devastating 2002 drought, that allows farmers, ranchers, water districts or other entities to temporarily loan water to rivers and streams in times of need.

“I think everyone was happy,” McBride said.  “I didn’t know of any real opposition.  And the river certainly benefited.”

Down to the River

Billy Atkinson, an aquatic biologist with Colorado Parks and Wildlife, dips his equipment into the river, and measures its temperature and dissolved oxygen. These are the river’s vitals, and Atkinson has been monitoring them all summer long.

It’s now August 21.  I’m tagging along with Atkinson on his daily routine with a team from National Geographic’s Freshwater Initiative.  Along with its partner, the Bonneville Environmental Foundation, National Geographic has contributed funds to the Colorado Water Trust to help pay for the water lease.  We’ve come to the Yampa to see and document what the lease is accomplishing – and what disasters it may have helped avoid.

Atkinson has been worried in particular about the native mountain whitefish, a close cousin of salmon and trout that is found in only two Colorado river basins, the Yampa and the White.  The whitefish population had declined alarmingly in the late nineties and, according to Atkinson, “really took a hit” in 2002.

Due to very low snowpack, late spring and summer flows of the Yampa River were a small fraction of the 101-year average. The 2012 peak flows also came a month earlier than normal. By June, when flows were 5-10 percent of normal, the river was at risk of ecological collapse. The drought lease began on June 28, lifting the river’s flows out of the danger zone. Drawn by Alex Eddy, data from U.S. Geological Survey.

 

When flows dropped so terribly low that year, Atkinson and other scientists witnessed that as the river warmed and filled with oxygen-robbing vegetation, the whitefish all gathered where the water was two degrees cooler, often in deeper pools behind rocks.  The fish used their limited energy to pump oxygen over their gills, leaving little for feeding and other activities. All hanging out in one place, they also competed for space and aquatic insects, which also declined in numbers due to the warmer, poor-quality water.

All in all, 2002 was a tough time for the native whitefish.  The main reason recreational tubing and kayaking are banned on the river when its flow drops below 85 cfs is to avoid further stressing the fish.

Atkinson also maintains and monitors a popular recreational, catch-and-release trout fishery.  It is not uncommon to see fly fisherman in the waters at dusk, dawn and even mid-day, casting their reels into the Yampa’s babbling riffles.

Thanks in part to July rains but also to the water lease, conditions for the fish this year are a “tremendous improvement” over 2002, Atkinson said.  The higher flows provide deeper, cooler water, which means more habitat, better oxygen levels and less predation pressure.

The drought lease “helped out significantly,” Atkinson said.

The next morning, we headed to Carpenter Ranch, about 20 miles downstream from Steamboat Springs. A pair of sandhill cranes peck in the fields for breakfast, their low staccato trumpet sounds filling the dawn air.  Perched high above the river, a juvenile bald eagle spies the river below, looking for a bite.

Here, adjacent to the Yampa, is a working ranch leased out by The Nature Conservancy that is also a sanctuary for birds and wildlife that call the river home.  Geoff Blakeslee, who started managing the ranch in 1996, is now the Conservancy’s Yampa River project director.

“The Yampa is the lifeblood of this valley,” Blakeslee said.

It’s also ecologically unique and valuable, with four endangered fish species and a globally rare plant community.  The narrow-leaf cottonwood, box elder and red-osier dogwood that thrive along the Yampa’s banks typically don’t exist together.  This rare plant assemblage is critical habitat for numerous animals, including more than 150 bird species that rely on it during migration.  They also nest and raise their young there.

By keeping flows above harmful levels, the lease also helped sustain this unique ecosystem and its many dependents.

Lee Curby, a young farmer who leases land at Carpenter Ranch, was also grateful for the leased water.  Earlier in the summer, before the lease went into action, Curby liquidated his herd of cattle because he feared not having a harvest sufficient to feed them.  Because Curby’s land was far downstream from the river reach targeted by the lease, and Carpenter Ranch owned senior water rights on the Yampa, the lease allowed Curby to divert enough water for a late-season harvest of hay.

“(We) irrigated just in time to get a crop,” Curby said.

All in all, the water lease looks like a win-win.  Or, as CWT’s Amy Beatie would say, “a win, win, win, win.”

From early July through September 15, the Yampa stream gage at Steamboat never registered less than 70 cfs.  While welcome July rains added measurably to the river’s flow, there’s no question that the drought lease staved off what might have been a disaster for the river and the town it runs through.

With climate scientists warning that the dice are loaded for more droughts in the western United States, innovative approaches like this water lease can help ensure that rivers, and the aquatic life and businesses that depend on them, survive the dry times.

Since it was structured as a one-year lease, there’s no guarantee that the Yampa will fare as well the next time a drought hits.  But this year’s success – and the multiple benefits it yielded – provides ample reason to develop similarly innovative schemes for the Yampa and other rivers in the future.

After all, for rivers that give so much to us, it only feels right to give something back in times of need.

Sandra Postel is director of the Global Water Policy Project and lead water expert for National Geographic’s Freshwater Initiative.  She is the author of several acclaimed books, including the award-winning Last Oasis, a Pew Scholar in Conservation and the Environment, and one of the “Scientific American 50.”

Special thanks to Silk and Coca-Cola, Charter Sponsors for Change the Course. Additional funding generously provided by the Walton Family Foundation.

To view a five-minute  video of this Yampa River story, click here.

 

 

 

Sandra Postel directs the independent Global Water Policy Project and lectures, writes, and consults on international water issues. She is also Freshwater Fellow of the National Geographic Society, and serves as lead water expert for the Society's freshwater initiative. Sandra is the author of several acclaimed books, including the award-winning Last Oasis, the basis for a PBS documentary. Her essay "Troubled Waters" was selected for Best American Science and Nature Writing. Sandra is a Pew Scholar in Conservation and the Environment, and has been named one of the "Scientific American 50" for her contributions to water policy.
  • Hi Shawn. We put the credit on there now, sorry for the omission.

  • Hi Shawn. We put the credit on there now, sorry for the omission.

  • Nathan Conroy

    Sandra, thank you for this article. I have been following the impressive work of various groups to make water leases and river restoration projects reality, especially the Fresh Water Trust in Oregon. At Marquette University we are trying to motivate today’s students to engage with these issues and share their perspective. To do that we are holding a blog competition with this year’s drought as the theme. We would love to showcase an original submission from you or perhaps a version of an existing piece. More information can be found here: blog.h2oscore.com Thanks.

  • Nathan Conroy

    Sandra, thank you for this article. I have been following the impressive work of various groups to make water leases and river restoration projects reality, especially the Fresh Water Trust in Oregon. At Marquette University we are trying to motivate today’s students to engage with these issues and share their perspective. To do that we are holding a blog competition with this year’s drought as the theme. We would love to showcase an original submission from you or perhaps a version of an existing piece. More information can be found here: blog.h2oscore.com Thanks.

  • Nate

    How do we prevent water that is kept in a dewatered river, thanks to a water lease, from simply becoming more available supply for downstream M&I users to withdraw? In other words, if water is added to a river through a water lease process, are downstream M&I users allowed to increase their withdraws if river flows go above the legal threshold where M&I curtailments are required? I’m concerned that increased flows from water leases might allow municipal water users to not have to encourage urban water conservation as much as they should.

    • Nate, you raise a good question. In the West, a water user can only divert if they have a legal “right” to the water. In the case of the Yampa, the leased water was protected in-stream for a crucial seven miles (no one had a right to divert and use it from this stretch), and because the leased water continued to flow downstream, benefits to the river extended far beyond that as well.

    • Nate, you raise a good question. In the West, a water user can only divert if they have a legal “right” to the water. In the case of the Yampa, the leased water was protected in-stream for a crucial seven miles (no one had a right to divert and use it from this stretch), and because the leased water continued to flow downstream, benefits to the river extended far beyond that as well.

  • Nate

    How do we prevent water that is kept in a dewatered river, thanks to a water lease, from simply becoming more available supply for downstream M&I users to withdraw? In other words, if water is added to a river through a water lease process, are downstream M&I users allowed to increase their withdraws if river flows go above the legal threshold where M&I curtailments are required? I’m concerned that increased flows from water leases might allow municipal water users to not have to encourage urban water conservation as much as they should.

  • Craig Middle School River Watch Class

    We enjoyed your article in our discussion on water usage in the Yampa. We are the River Watch class from Craig Middle School and are located on the lower Yampa. Our class has been collecting data since 1991 in partnership with Colorado Parks and Wildlife. We collect data on chemistry (hardness, pH, alkalinity, DO and heavy metals) Biologic indicators such as aquatic insects, physical erosion and helping tag and monitoring Northern Pike on our river. It was nice to see an article that directly discussed the Yampa and touched on current issues with the drought. We noticed with our fall macroinvertabrate collection that the numbers of insects were above normal and those found were indicators of a healthy watershed. The good news is the water is rising! . Thanks. CMS waterwatchers

    • Thanks for your work to monitor and study the Yampa’s health – and for letting us know about it! It sounds like a great collaboration with Colorado Parks and Wildlife. Keep up the great work!

    • Thanks for your work to monitor and study the Yampa’s health – and for letting us know about it! It sounds like a great collaboration with Colorado Parks and Wildlife. Keep up the great work!

  • Craig Middle School River Watch Class

    We enjoyed your article in our discussion on water usage in the Yampa. We are the River Watch class from Craig Middle School and are located on the lower Yampa. Our class has been collecting data since 1991 in partnership with Colorado Parks and Wildlife. We collect data on chemistry (hardness, pH, alkalinity, DO and heavy metals) Biologic indicators such as aquatic insects, physical erosion and helping tag and monitoring Northern Pike on our river. It was nice to see an article that directly discussed the Yampa and touched on current issues with the drought. We noticed with our fall macroinvertabrate collection that the numbers of insects were above normal and those found were indicators of a healthy watershed. The good news is the water is rising! . Thanks. CMS waterwatchers

  • Nicholas Flores

    Great success story. Thank you Sandra.

  • Nicholas Flores

    Great success story. Thank you Sandra.

  • Mathew Rawlings

    A good example of using the water rights market to help solve water problems. Good article.

  • Mathew Rawlings

    A good example of using the water rights market to help solve water problems. Good article.

  • Larry Kobayashi

    Sandra,

    Thank you for the wonderful video and article on this innovative approach to dealing with drought conditions. We’re looking at the increasing water vulnerability brought about by climate change of businesses, and I wonder if this approach could be used by a coalition of businesses (both recreational and manufacturers) which rely on the river for their livelihoods.

    • Larry, I would think it could. A coalition of businesses that depend on adequate river flow might provide the funding to purchase such a water lease during drought times, because it would benefit their businesses as well as the river. This is exactly the kind of innovative management (and funding sources) that will be needed. Thanks for your comment.

    • Larry, I would think it could. A coalition of businesses that depend on adequate river flow might provide the funding to purchase such a water lease during drought times, because it would benefit their businesses as well as the river. This is exactly the kind of innovative management (and funding sources) that will be needed. Thanks for your comment.

  • Larry Kobayashi

    Sandra,

    Thank you for the wonderful video and article on this innovative approach to dealing with drought conditions. We’re looking at the increasing water vulnerability brought about by climate change of businesses, and I wonder if this approach could be used by a coalition of businesses (both recreational and manufacturers) which rely on the river for their livelihoods.

  • Nomusa Mguni-Mhlanga

    I appreciate the practical lessons on community cooperation to save a river and its flaura and fauna and giving a lifeline to businesses that depend on the river. My home town of Bulawayo is reeling under the effects of a drought that has left the city’s supply dams nearly empty. Rains received so far (Nearly a month into the official rainy season) are not promising a bright future at all. Research on the impacts of unregulated mining activities in the City’s supply dams catchments as well as harnessing of treated wastewater for reuse by the city might provide solutions to the water deficit. These challenges have motivated the creation of the Foundation for Water and Environment Research whose focus is to look for solutions for water and environmental management in this semi-arid region of Zimbabwe. This article has inspired me to operationalize the Foundation’s proposed projects and come up with practical solutions that will save the heritage associated with the historical city Bulawayo.

  • Nomusa Mguni-Mhlanga

    I appreciate the practical lessons on community cooperation to save a river and its flaura and fauna and giving a lifeline to businesses that depend on the river. My home town of Bulawayo is reeling under the effects of a drought that has left the city’s supply dams nearly empty. Rains received so far (Nearly a month into the official rainy season) are not promising a bright future at all. Research on the impacts of unregulated mining activities in the City’s supply dams catchments as well as harnessing of treated wastewater for reuse by the city might provide solutions to the water deficit. These challenges have motivated the creation of the Foundation for Water and Environment Research whose focus is to look for solutions for water and environmental management in this semi-arid region of Zimbabwe. This article has inspired me to operationalize the Foundation’s proposed projects and come up with practical solutions that will save the heritage associated with the historical city Bulawayo.

About the Blog

Researchers, conservationists, and others share stories, insights and ideas about Our Changing Planet, Wildlife & Wild Spaces, and The Human Journey. More than 50,000 comments have been added to 10,000 posts. Explore the list alongside to dive deeper into some of the most popular categories of the National Geographic Society’s conversation platform Voices.

Opinions are those of the blogger and/or the blogger’s organization, and not necessarily those of the National Geographic Society. Posters of blogs and comments are required to observe National Geographic’s community rules and other terms of service.

Voices director: David Braun (dbraun@ngs.org)

Social Media