Changing Planet

Caribbean Nations Must Think Bigger and Act Boldly and Soon to Sustain Ocean Resources

I was honored to be asked to speak at the Caribbean Challenge Initiative’s Summit of Political and Business Leaders, which took place in the British Virgin Islands May 17th and 18th. (See AP story for an overview of the event.)

Caribbean Challenge Initiative Summit

I spoke from the heart, and here is what I said:

At the risk of being controversial, I would like to offer my honest take. The #1 threat to coral reefs is lack of political will and sense of corporate responsibility. It’s great that this summit is focused on those two groups, but we need much more progress on this front. Apart from that, the primary threat has long been overfishing, and that is now being joined by, and soon to be eclipsed by, climate change. Pollution and habitat destruction are at #3 and #4, the order depending on your location.

I was invited to speak about overfishing. Overfishing is a serious, serious problem. But there are simple solutions: DON’T CATCH AS MANY AS YOU CAN, EVERYWHERE YOU CAN, ALL OF THE TIME, WITH WHATEVER MEANS YOU WANT.

That means limiting the amount of fish that you take out of the ocean (i.e., total allowable catch). That means closed areas  (i.e. fish sanctuaries, reserves where no fishing occurs). That means closed seasons (i.e., times of the year when you do not fish for certain species). And that means restricting and banning some types of fishing gear (i.e., gear that damages habitat, targets juveniles, has high bycatch) – proliferating use of nets is the primary problem here.

All these measures amount to: give the fish and the reefs a break. Give them a respite, a chance to reproduce and replenish. Then fishing can be sustained at a higher level and be more profitable, and there will be more for tourists to see.

If there is one thing you should focus on to improve the health of coral reefs and the fisheries that depend on them it is protecting key herbivores: parrotfish and surgeonfish. They are the lawnmowers of the reef that eat the algae so slow-growing coral stands a chance. They are not choice fish in the Caribbean – there is not a strong cultural/traditional attachment to consuming these species.

Necker Island, British Virgin Islands. Privately owned by Richard Branson, and Summit site.

Belize enacted a ban on catching parrotfish and surgeonfish two years ago, and it is well supported by the community. Parrotfish and surgeonfish are only being heavily targeted now because they are the most abundant fish left after severe depletion of groupers and snappers. However, political and business leaders at this Summit committed to focus on creating regional protection for sharks and rays. I think that misses the point; that’s low hanging fruit, and it is not what is needed to restore coral reef ecosystems.

In mulling over all the speeches I heard yesterday, the almost entirely vague commitments made by political and business leaders, at first I thought that what we needed was to be more ambitious, to set bigger goals. But really it’s that we need to be more practical. In a region that is so heavily dependent on tourism related to healthy ocean resources, it is simply bad business to allow those resources to continue to degrade.

100% of the ocean should be managed. Managed just means to have a plan. And the goal of that plan should be to increase the quantity of fish closer to their former abundances, and to fish in a way that is sustainable. So I would implore you to be MUCH more visionary than the Caribbean Challenge goal of 20% managed by 2020. If I had gotten to write the goals for the Caribbean Challenge I would have written: 100% of ocean area managed by 2020, and 20% of ocean areas set aside in fish sanctuaries that are completely closed to fishing.

You may say this sounds extreme, but all this really means is treating the ocean more like the land. You don’t just let people bulldoze willy nilly on land, you require permits for development; there are limited areas for industrial use; there are parks; there are farming areas. You should do the same for the ocean.

There is room for creativity in solutions. One such solution for sustainable fishing is the research that won me the Rare/National Geographic Solution Search prize. If you put a slot, a vertical and rectangular escape gap, in the corner of a fish trap you can reduce bycatch by 80% without at all reducing the value of fishermen’s catches. There are other such solutions ready for implementation.

There is also room for needed national and local specificity, but really we all need to think bigger. Not just protected areas, but comprehensive, island-wide zoning of entire coastal oceans or even entire exclusive economic zones, based on science, and with deep stakeholder engagement. That is the approach the Waitt Foundation is taking with initiatives in Bermuda and Barbuda, and we hope to do more of that holistic work in the near future. So if any islands represented here are interested in taking that approach, let’s talk.

Well, someone had to jump on Sir Richard's trampoline.
Well, someone had to jump on Sir Richard’s trampoline.

P.S. The list of commitments made at the Summit is now available. Look for yourself and see if you think these measures show adequate vision, financial commitment, and concreteness. Overall, I remain disappointed. (With the exception of Bamboo Sushi who is doing a lot for a small company.)

Dr. Ayana Elizabeth Johnson is a marine biologist, policy expert, conservation strategist, and Brooklyn native. She is founder and president of Ocean Collectiv, a consulting firm for ocean conservation strategies grounded in social justice. She teaches at New York University as an adjunct professor, and was co-director of partnerships for the March for Science. As executive director of the Waitt Institute, Ayana co-founded the Blue Halo Initiative and led the Caribbean’s first successful island-wide ocean zoning effort. Previously, she worked on ocean policy at the EPA and NOAA, and was recently a TED resident and Aspen Institute fellow. She envisions and works toward a healthy ocean that supports food security, economies, and cultures. Find her @ayanaeliza.
  • Braulio Dias, Executive Secretary of the CBD

    Dear Ayana,
    I appreciated very much the bold and frank statement you gave us at the recent Caribbean Leaders Summit in the BVI on the occasion of the launching of phase 2 of the Cabibbean Challenge Initiative. We need more people like you with concrete and practical solutions to ‘walk the talk’ towards more action. Best regards, Braulio

  • Braulio, thanks very much for your supportive comment. I am *very* cautiously optimistic that we’ll see some meaningful actions soon.

  • Joy Elvin

    I hope that perhaps this article is a synopsis of your talk, as there is no mention of the ground breaking work the BVI have done to protect their coral reefs and fish populations. The reef protection programme run by the National Parks Trust has been in operation since the late 1980’s, the Conservation and Fisheries Department have also introduced many initiatives since the early 1990’s under the then head, Bertrand Lettsome, both of which continue today. Then there is the mangrove restoration work and the volunteer programme to remove Lion fish from the waters. If your talk was given without reference to any of this, or other work being done by several other organisations, then I fear that it would not have been received favourably.
    Sincerely, Joy Elvin.

  • Joy, thank you for reading and taking the time to comment. My remarks do not mean to take away from the very hard and important work of individuals, or the progress that has been made in some specific locations. My point is that if you look at the Caribbean as a region, or even at any one nation, the overall trend in the last 50 years is a decline in health of ocean resources (the reefs and fish populations are but a shadow of their former state), and the actions taken to date have not been big or bold enough to turn that around, and committing to managing 20% also won’t be enough turn that around. Examples of good management, perhaps including the ones you mention, are enormously valuable, but that value is only realized if those efforts are replicated and scaled up. I see that as the work we have ahead of us.

  • Lisa Sullivan

    No one has no idea how bad it is. The beaches of Rincon Puerto Rico are like the canary in the coal mine. What once was 100 yards that is 3600 feet of sand and a coastline of palm trees 27 years ago down to 5 feet as of today is the reality. After surges from hurricanes, giant condos condoned by corrupt political officials and theft of sand to make the concrete in those ugly condos plus seawalls, no plan no nothing but individual greed and Money we the people of Puerto Rico and the United States have no beaches. Forget tourism forget small business owners forget people enjoying a beautiful gift from Mother Nature. I do not have hope for the beaches of that Island. They do not care and they only tell you they care or are in denial or pass the buck. The only plan is now Federal and one that will embrace the whole coastline, embrace homeowners, create an overall comprehensive stop erosion save the beach unified plan or alternative is kiss the beaches goodbye.

  • Mikell O’Mealy

    Thanks very much for highlighting the key issues and needs so clearly, Ayana. Well done.

About the Blog

Researchers, conservationists, and others share stories, insights and ideas about Our Changing Planet, Wildlife & Wild Spaces, and The Human Journey. More than 50,000 comments have been added to 10,000 posts. Explore the list alongside to dive deeper into some of the most popular categories of the National Geographic Society’s conversation platform Voices.

Opinions are those of the blogger and/or the blogger’s organization, and not necessarily those of the National Geographic Society. Posters of blogs and comments are required to observe National Geographic’s community rules and other terms of service.

Voices director: David Braun (dbraun@ngs.org)

Social Media