National Geographic Society Newsroom

Blue Collar Working Dogs to the Rescue!

I recently rescued a young male doberman from a doberman rescue in Southern California. Although I was seeking a companion pet, I dedicated some time to learning more about this breed in terms of the purpose it was intended to serve as a working dog. In recent years, our society has embraced the “mutt” due...

I recently rescued a young male doberman from a doberman rescue in Southern California. Although I was seeking a companion pet, I dedicated some time to learning more about this breed in terms of the purpose it was intended to serve as a working dog.

In recent years, our society has embraced the “mutt” due to the need of so many mixed breed dogs in need of lifelong care.

There is still, however, a place for the “purebred” dog  particularly among the modern working breeds, which were carefully developed to serve in an array of capacities from protection, and herding, to tracking and detection.

The doberman, which originates from Germany, was developed as a working breed and eventually by the late 20th Century was used specifically to provide protective services to owners and clients. Most dobermans are now commonly purchased or adopted as pets and many are bred to be show dogs. Some are trained for protection by both the private and public sector, which include those trained to work with law enforcement agencies and the military.

Since the tragic events at last year’s Boston Marathon, security has been heightened at public events nationwide and with this increase in security more trained dogs have been recruited to help protect the public.

I reached out to working dog trainer Barry Hewitt. Barry owns Blue Collar Working Dog in Los Angeles, which sells dog training accessories to trainers and handlers of protection dogs and dogs, which provide other services.To my knowledge, it is the only store of its kind on the planet.

Jordan: I walked in to your store and was amazed at the accessories available in the commercial market for the training of protection dogs. Is there a growing demand for protection dog services?

Barry: Yes,  There seems to be a growing fear with our societal issues. People are feeling the need to protect themselves, and property.  Also, I hear a lot of people saying that they wouldn’t want to own a gun.  The odds of hurting yourself with your own gun is higher then the odds of getting hurt by an assailant.  The next best thing to owning a gun, would be a protection dog. Walking down the street with a dog on your side is less menacing to the public, then walking with a gun strapped to your side.  Protection dogs are very popular with families that have kids.  Parents feel that they could leave their child out playing in the front yard alone with a dog and not have to worry someone may come by and kidnap them.

Jordan: What are some of the most popular or preferred protection dog breeds and how are they sourced?

Barry: The German Shepherd is still the most popular protection dog breed.  Especially with families. They’re stable in temperament, have a medium to high drive and they have a natural herding instinct. This calmer and more stable disposition makes them better as a family protection dog than the other more “militant” working dogs such as the Belgian Malinois or Dutch Shepherd. However, we are seeing the German Shepherd used less and less by professional handlers. The Belgian Shepherd (Malinios)  is becoming extremely popular (especially after the Bin Ladan capture) with the military, police, border patrol, search and rescue and for use in personal protection .  These extremely athletic and high drive dogs are “the go to dog” for professional handlers. They also are a bit smaller than the German Shepherd (you can throw them over your shoulder, boost them over a wall, etc.) yet they can jump higher and move faster and are much healthier due to the fact that they have not been “overbred” yet by reckless American backyard breeders. Due to their extreme high drive and sharp character The Malinois and the Dutchie aren’t recommended for families that have kids, but there are certain breeders that are making them more “stable” and we are now starting to see them in more homes. Other popular dogs for family personal protection are the  Rottweiler, and the Doberman pincher, although you will seldom see them used in military or police operations. For strictly scent-working, it is still the labrador and the blood hound. But if you want an all purpose dog who is athletic, protective and can do scent detection work, the Malinois and Dutchie is the breed.

The genetics of working dogs is very important. Genetics plays an important role in temperament, personality, intelligence and general health. Historically, the best genetics have come from  Europe.  Europe retains very strict breeding laws and because of this the dogs coming from countries like Germany, Slovakia, Belgium, Hungary, Holland, France and Czech Republic will have much better genetics.  Even today most of the American police and military dogs are being imported from Europe. In the United States, anyone can breed a dog, and if you mail in some paperwork you can get some sort of AKC recognition for that dog. Due to low, or “no” standards in the US, we have totally washed out the genetic pool and created some pretty unhealthy and “unworkable” dogs.  But, there are a handful of good breeders here, that really do take the time to consider what they are putting together.

Jordan: As an exotic animal trainer, I learned to train and condition large carnivores through the use of positive reinforcement techniques, which are commonly used for working with companion animals.  But in the past decade there has been a resurgence of dominance-based training as a means to interact and teach obedience to dogs. Can you talk about the kind of training techniques that most protection dogs are subjected to?

blue_dog - 24
Photograph courtesy Blue Collar Working Dog.

Barry: I think the resurgence of dominance- based training is coming from Cesar Milan.  In my opinion, some of his techniques are good for certain situations.  We have to consider that Cesar Milan is trying to “fix” existing behavioral problems, and he must do this relatively quickly. Of course positive reinforcement is, in my opinion, the only way to go when you train a dog from the beginning. But, it can be quite laborious and time consuming if you use it to fix deep issues. To use positive reinforcement in fixing issues one needs to create an extremely controlled environment, any and all people that interact with the dog must be on board and they all must be vigilant. This doesn’t necessarily work for most families and it certainly doesn’t work for trainers who are hoping to get paid in just a few sessions. Unfortunately, the world of working dog trainers is still very compulsion based, but the new breed or working dog trainers (myself included) raise a working dog right from the beginning through positive reinforcement techniques. Plus, they incorporate an extremely controlled environment. Then you wont have to “Cesar Milan” your dog later on.

But, we must keep in mind that we are working with dogs that have been bred for certain qualities and one of those qualities is “hardness”. Working dog trainers mostly believe that to handle a hard dog you had to have a hard hand. That if you do not correct a sharp and hard dog, the dog will one day run you over. To a certain extent, this is true. But the new progressive trainers, are proving that positive based training makes the dog WANT to work harder and with more gusto. We use a dogs natural curiosity and “seeking” behavior as a reward and we get excellent results. We now USE that hardness and drive to our advantage with reinforcement methods. But again, this can best be done from the puppy stage and within a controlled environment. Old school compulsion based trainers will get a dog they have to kennel up at the end of a shift. With positive training, you get an overall more balanced, confident dog who is willing to work. I’m a staunch supporter of positive training in working dogs.

Jordan: What are some of the needs of your client base with regard to dog training and who are your clients, generally speaking?

Barry: Most of the dogs I train are used in working-dog competition sports. These competition sports go by different names dependent on the country: IPO, French Ring, Mondio Ring, KNPV, NVBK, PSA to name a few. They were started as a way to gauge the work-ability of police and military dogs in Europe. They test both the handler and the dog in obedience, bite-work, agility, scent work and courage. Titles in these sports are used to rate certain breeds, lines and breeders.  Even American working dogs are judged and purchased due to the titles the dogs have earned in these competitions. These sports are gaining popularity.  The dogs I train compete in these sports. I also train dogs for personal protection.

Jordan: Can you talk about the future of working dogs in general. Do you see them being used more so in explosive detection or protection or in other capacities?

Photograph courtesy Jordan Schaul.

Barry: The future of the working dog is great. I see them being used more and more in police, military and in society as well.  It seems that dogs are more utilized for scent-work than they are for protection work. We still haven’t developed a machine that can out perform a dog’s nose in finding specific scents.   There are explosive dogs, drug dogs, search dogs, cadaver dogs, bed bug dogs, cancer cell dogs, mold dogs and just about every other type of scent dog.  The list goes on and on.  If there is a scent to be found, dogs can find it.

The use of dogs in medical support is also very popular. We all know how dogs can assist people with medical conditions such as blindness, paralysis, mobility issues, etc. But, dogs are now being also used in psychiatric support as well. They have been proven effective not only for emotional support  but also for assisting people with autism, PTSD, Alzheimer’s, etc. The dog is truly “man’s best friend.”  We will be continuing to find other ways for the dog to help us.

About National Geographic Society

The National Geographic Society is a global nonprofit organization that uses the power of science, exploration, education and storytelling to illuminate and protect the wonder of our world. Since 1888, National Geographic has pushed the boundaries of exploration, investing in bold people and transformative ideas, providing more than 14,000 grants for work across all seven continents, reaching 3 million students each year through education offerings, and engaging audiences around the globe through signature experiences, stories and content. To learn more, visit or follow us on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook.

Meet the Author

Author Photo Jordan Carlton Schaul
With training in wildlife ecology, conservation medicine and comparative psychology, Dr. Schaul's contributions to Nat Geo Voices have covered a range of environmental and social topics. He draws particular attention to the plight of imperiled species highlighting issues at the juncture or nexus of sorta situ wildlife conservation and applied animal welfare. Sorta situ conservation practices are comprised of scientific management and stewardship of animal populations ex situ (in captivity / 'in human care') and in situ (free-ranging / 'in nature'). He also has a background in behavior management and training of companion animals and captive wildlife, as well as conservation marketing and digital publicity. Jordan has shared interviews with colleagues and public figures, as well as editorial news content. In addition, he has posted narratives describing his own work, which include the following examples: • Restoration of wood bison to the Interior of Alaska while (While Animal Curator at Alaska Wildlife Conservation Center and courtesy professor at the University of Alaska) • Rehabilitation of orphaned sloth bears exploited for tourists in South Asia (While executive consultant 'in-residence' at the Agra Bear Rescue Center managed by Wildlife SOS) • Censusing small wild cat (e.g. ocelot and margay) populations in the montane cloud forests of Costa Rica for popular publications with 'The Cat Whisperer' Mieshelle Nagelschneider • Evaluating the impact of ecotourism on marine mammal population stability and welfare off the coast of Mexico's Sea of Cortez (With Boston University's marine science program) Jordan was a director on boards of non-profit wildlife conservation organizations serving nations in Africa, North and South America and Southeast Asia. He is also a consultant to a human-wildlife conflict mitigation organization in the Pacific Northwest. Following animal curatorships in Alaska and California, he served as a charter board member of a zoo advocacy and outreach organization and later as its executive director. Jordan was a member of the Communication and Education Commission of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (CEC-IUCN) and the Bear Specialist Group of the IUCN Species Survival Commission (BSG-SSC-IUCN). He has served on the advisory council of the National Wildlife Humane Society and in service to the Bear Taxon Advisory Group of the Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA Bear TAG). In addition he was an ex officio member of council of the International Association for Bear Research and Management. Contact Email: