“Remarkable” New Salamander Disguises Itself as a Baby

A newfound species of lungless salamander from Arkansas seems to be sipping from a fountain of youth.

From the outside, the recently discovered Ouachita streambed salamander (Eurycea subfluvicola) looks like the larval form of a related species, the many-ribbed salamander (Eurycea multiplicata). But on the inside, the “remarkable” amphibian is obviously an adult, with a fully developed reproductive system, a new study says.

An adult female Ouachita streambed salamander (E. subfluvicola). Photograph by Michael A. Steffen

The phenomenon of adult organisms keeping a youthful appearance, called paedomorphism, is well known in nature. But E. subfluvicola is the most extreme example found in salamanders in more than 70 years, according to scientists, and the first ever found in Arkansas’ Ouachita Mountains (map).

Compared with its relative, the many-ribbed salamander, the new species has a shorter and narrower head; a flatter, longer snout; and darker, more depressed eyes. Most noticeably, the new salamander doesn’t have the trademark black stripe that runs down its relatives’ heads and noses, according to the study, published April 11 in the journal Zootaxa.

As with any animal family, it’s extremely rare to find a new species living “under the same rock” as its closest relative, said study co-author Mike Steffen, a biology Ph.D. candidate at the University of Tulsa in Oklahoma, who first found the new animal.

Youthful Masquerade

On May 23, 2011, Steffen was collecting many-ribbed salamanders from a mountain creek in Lake Catherine State Park. Short on adult samples, he scooped up a few larvae.

Back at the lab, he dissected the larvae and ran genetic tests. One contained developing eggs, but he thought, “Eh, whatever, it’s just an anomaly,” and moved on. (Also see “U.S. Giant Salamanders Slipping Away: Inside the Fight to Save the Hellbender.”)

When the tests came back, though, one was “really different.” He assumed it was a mistake, but a quick look at his field notes revealed that the unique results belonged to the same sample that had contained the developing eggs. So, it hadn’t been an anomaly—the specimen had been a mature adult, disguised as a larva.

With co-author Kelly Irwin, of the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission, Steffen sequenced a few more of the odd animal’s genes and found the same result. They’d found a new species of paedomorphic salamander.

Confirming the new species meant finding another specimen—and that would take another two years.

Confirming the Find

The spring of 2012 was drier than usual—not good conditions for salamanders—and Steffen failed to find a matching salamander. He again started to wonder if he’d made some kind of mistake. Then, on an unseasonably warm day in February 2013, Steffen and Irwin scooped up a salamander identical to the 2011 specimen. A month later, Steffen found several more.

A photo of two salamanders.
An adult female Ouachita streambed salamander (bottom) and the larval form of its closest relative, the many-ribbed salamander (top). Photograph by Michael A. Steffen

“You can see through the belly really easily,” Steffen said, and “you can look for reproductive organs if you move them around a little bit.” When he saw mature testes in the young-looking salamanders, he knew he had the right species.

Ultimately, he collected and tested 24 additional animals, which confirmed the discovery of a new species.

Why E. subfluvicola evolved to disguise itself as a youngster is unknown, but the scientists suspect that its youthful form gives it access to an otherwise unexploited part of the streambed and prevents it from breeding with the related species.

According to their genetic research, the team estimates that E. subfluvicola and E. multiplicata became separate species about 18 million years ago.

Right Under His Nose 

Despite thoroughly searching the region, the scientists found E. subfluvicola in only two areas of the same creek system, and its rarity should be of “immediate conservation concern,” according to the study. (Read about vanishing amphibians in National Geographic magazine.)

“There could be other paedamorphic salamanders,” Steffen added, explaining that many researchers do not collect larval samples. They could be stepping right over new species without knowing it—just as he nearly did in May 2011.

“If we happened to find three many-ribbed salamander larvae on that day instead of two many-ribbed and the new species, we would probably never have known about this species.”

Follow Danielle Elliot on Twitter and Facebook.

Danielle Elliot is a multimedia producer and writer who earned her chops reporting and producing for networks, start-ups, and everything in between. A graduate of the University of Maryland, she covered tennis and Olympic figure skating for a few years before earning an M.A. in Science and Health Journalism at Columbia University. Follow her on Twitter @daniellelliot.
  • salam khan

    Good jobe

  • Pamela Butler

    How fascinating. Congratulations on the newly found species of salamander.

  • Danielle Elliot

    Pam, I can tell you they were very excited about it!

  • Habil chitwa

    Keep on the good you are doing natgeo

  • Rita Neu

    I am concerned that so many specimens, of what appears to to be a very small population of “immediate conservation concern”, were taken for testing, which appears to mean that they were destroyed in the process.

    • Hi Rita,

      The researchers were actually able to keep most of the specimens alive by doing what they call a “tip test” — they take tissue samples from the tip of the tail, which later regenerates.

  • Steve

    Why, oh why, do you insist on claiming evolution to be fact. There is no “fact” in evolution except that it is THEORY. Species we have failed to identify previously, do not indicate some creature has evolved either. Yea, you go on evolving, and see where it gets you. I think little, if any, improvement might be noticed. Maybe in two million years, you will still look like…. dust.

  • Darrell H. Leacock

    I do not have at hand the name of the author of the following quote, but here it is for those who will not understand it.
    ” You may not be a candidate for genius, however it is your choice to remain ignorant”

  • Christina Zumwalt

    Interesting! The details of how the reproductive isolation and speciation occurred are fun to think about.

  • Eduardo Serrano

    Ir reminds me the AJOLOTE native from México city valley. Could it be the same?

  • Justin Thyme

    And unknown to him, he scooped up and dissected the last remaining 24 members of this new species.

  • Todd Davis

    Late winter,2011. One weekend I had several friends come in town, we decided to do some fishing. A cold sat night we ran a trol line in the main channel of Hamilton , between 70 and 270. Not until now I know what we encountered when we checked out lines. Without a doubt that is it. We have pictures and short video clip. We released it back in the lake

About the Blog

Researchers, conservationists, and others share stories, insights and ideas about Our Changing Planet, Wildlife & Wild Spaces, and The Human Journey. More than 50,000 comments have been added to 10,000 posts. Explore the list alongside to dive deeper into some of the most popular categories of the National Geographic Society’s conversation platform Voices.

Opinions are those of the blogger and/or the blogger’s organization, and not necessarily those of the National Geographic Society. Posters of blogs and comments are required to observe National Geographic’s community rules and other terms of service.

Voices director: David Braun (dbraun@ngs.org)

Social Media